Conferences: Paris: Summary

NEW:

Power-point presentations available to download

Cities netwroking and Inter-communality, key relays for a World Heritage Policy
by Yves DAUGE, Senator of the Indre et Loire, Mayor of Chinon (France)
Loire Valley.ppt Laos.ppt

The City of Lyon, a World Heritgae City
by Mr. Gérard COLLOMB, Senator of the Rhône (Rhône-Alpes) and Mayor of Lyon (France)

Lyon.ppt

Decentralisation and protection of heritage in Asia: the case of Thailand
by Mr. Kraisak CHOONAVAN, Senator, President of the Foreign Affairs Commission of the Senate of the Kingdom of Thailand
Thailand.ppt

SUMMARY of the CONFERENCE:

Mr. C. PONCELET (President of the French Sénat): The President of the French Sénat opened the conference by welcoming the UNESCO Director-General, all present, and thanking Senator Yves Dauge, who played a prominent role in the organisation of this event. Mr. Poncelet is pleased the theme of the conference will be on decentralisation and heritage. He underlined the utility of exploring ideas on decentralisation for reforms, and urged those in the Sénat to prepare propositions in this domain. His message focused on the need for each region to look after its heritage and establish shared aims among the population. At the international level, each of country should reaffirm its part in the universal.

Mr. K. MATSUURA (UNESCO Director-General): After giving sincere gratitude for being invited to this gathering of exchanges on themes of decentralization, the Director-General stressed the importance of 2002 as the Year for Cultural Heritage, as well as the year we will celebrate the 30th Anniversary of the Convention Concerning the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage. UNESCO is the only United Nations Organization with a mandate for culture, and it has become increasingly important that action for the protection of cultural heritage be taken on regional and local levels. Approach towards heritage has changed, since the out-set, most ideas on heritage revolved around the monument, and has now evolved to include natural and intangible heritage, and most recently, bio-diversity. World Heritage List enriched each year. Greater international solidarity is essential to ensure heritage is passed down from one generation to another. Our intangible heritage is at risk from globalisation. Urgency for national and international action is needed. Government has a duty to protect and ensure players concerned. Stakeholders can ensure budget and bring awareness to public. Sénat is very important body, and Matsuura reiterated his hope that the French government will pass policies accessible to all.

M. C PONCELET (President of the French Sénat): He has received the message and understands that the “ball is in their court.” Landmarks of human history are vestiges of history, and we should do all that we can to protect them. Each must, within their jurisdiction, do what they can to ensure success: future generations should know what their ancestors have done, and use that as an example.

H.E. Mr. J. MUSITELLI (Ambassador, Permanent Delegation of France to UNESCO): Great pleasure and honour to chair. DG and Poncelet speech set the stage for a great event. Morning session on European perspectives. Symposium is part of a series of events around the world, each focusing on a specific theme.

Mr. M. BOUCHENAKI (Assistant Director-General, UNESCO Culture Sector): Synthesis of history of conventions and implementation of standard setting practices. UNESCO has been working towards heritage through operational activities and in conceptual terms: ICOMOS, ICCROM, etc, for example are some of the key players that define UNESCO’s mission in heritage. Items damaged during the Second WW spurred the 1954 Hague Convention, which had a broad reaching mandate to cover all heritage, not only museum goods. The 1970 Convention against the illicit trafficking of artefacts preceded the 1972 Convention on World Heritage. Bouchenaki reiterated that this Convention had much ground work. The natural threats against the Abu Simbel site in Egypt received much international attention, making it clear that people, the world over view World Heritage as something belonging to everyone. Most recently, UNESCO hopes to establish a standard setting for intangible heritage.

Mr. T. FEJERDY (President, World Heritage Committee): Indicated the existence of several complex problems that we face concerning the World Heritage Conservation. This year at the 26th session of the World Heritage Committee, the Budapest Declaration was adopted to ensure sound balance between conservation and development, and to ensure active participation of local communities for management. Authenticity, development and participation are all crucial elements concerning the World Heritage activities, as was expressed in the 1994 Nara Declaration. Fejerdy explained the process of nomination and listing of a World Heritage as a long process requiring good presentation and necessary procedures, such as management plans. Some sites have security problems (Albania given as an example), and there are sites, which reach a certain level of severity that their removal from the question of whether a site should be removed from the World Heritage List is considered. There are 2 kinds of Lists: the World Heritage List and the List of World Heritage in Danger. The latter is composed of properties, which are endangered by traffic, construction of contemporary buildings, affected by natural resources and circumstances, and developments projects such as mining, etc. Angkor, in Cambodia is one of the endangered sites where the protection of the quality of life of the local community must be balanced with tourism development and trafficking of stolen property. In order to solve the complex problems, there is a regular reporting system through monitoring the World Heritage sites. There are also thematic programmes funded by the World Heritage Fund, where international technical assistance is given for forests, sustainable tourism, cities and earthen architecture. Fejerdy concluded by reiterating that heritage is not only for tourists but for the whole living community, promoting their identity. It is vital that the international society safeguard them.

H.E. Mr. J. MUSITELLI (Ambassador, Permanent Delegation of France to UNESCO): To place a site on the World Heritage List is only the beginning of a series of challenges confronting the World Heritage Committee. The true responsibility is finding the balance between protecting and sustaining a site.

Mr. J. FAVIER (President, French National Commission to UNESCO): The World Heritage List brings pride and economic interest to a site. Policy making on the national and international level is vital, as is an awareness campaign. The process of decentralisation is becoming a part of our contemporary history. However, challenges occur on the level of local authority: World Heritage is a part of people’s daily life, particularly those who live near them. What is the point of listing a site if there is no interest locally? There is a responsibility to promote the site. Management work on sites should be ensured for visitors from other parts of the world, in order to show the value and dignity of their site that is considered as of universal value. We must breathe life into heritage, since heritage should be a living thing.

H.E. Mr. J. MUSITELLI (Ambassador, Permanent Delegation of France to UNESCO): France has a France-UNESCO Convention, adopted in 1997, which has also set a framework for decentralization. Decentralized cooperation can only succeed when local players, central government and UNESCO have good relay work.

Mr. A. JOHNSSON (Secretary-General, Inter-parliamentary Union): Mr. Johnsson expressed regret that he would not be able to attend and sent the following message to Mr. Bandarain, Director of the UNESCO World Heritage Centre, which was read by HE Ambassador Musitelli:

    As we have witnessed many recent resolutions at the Inter-Parliamentary Union (IPU), in particular on the Dialogue Among Civilisations and Cultures, adopted at the 103rd Conference, which took place in Amman (Jordan) in May 2000, and on Education and Culture as Essential Factors in Promoting the Participation of Men and Women in Political Life and as Prerequisites for the Development of Peoples, adopted at the 105th Conference in Havana in April 2001, which notably affirmed that the “only strong cultural roots enable individuals and societies to develop critical awareness, shape the present and the future and meet the challenges they pose advisedly, and that protecting and preserving cultural heritage is therefore an important political task.” The IPU is profoundly attached to the defence of cultural diversity in face of commercialisation of tangible and intangible heritage. The IPU would also like to join together, with those attending the conference on World Heritage, the Challenge for Decentralization, organized within the framework of the 30th Anniversary of the World Heritage Convention, in examining the responsibilities of elected officials, particularly local stakeholders, in heritage management, and achieving results in the inventory of work foreseen on heritage and decentralization.

Closure of first session

Mr. G. COLLOMB (Senator of the Rhône, Rhône-Alpes and Mayor of Lyon, France): The evaluation, safeguarding and nomination of Lyon went through 3 phases: 1) The establishment of the Sector of Safeguarding Old Lyon in 1964; 2) Creation of ZPPAUP (Zone for the Protection of Urban Landscape and Heritage), Lyon-Villaurban; and 3) Historical site of Lyon nominated as World Heritage in 1998. Heritage is not mearly a still monument; it is the city itself, which is a living organism, and is constantly changing. Lyon has an original geographical setting, with Rhône and the Soane Rivers merging, and two hills in the North and West of the city, that render the landscape unique. 85 % of the classified monuments are in 10% of the City’s overall surface (50 ha). 55% of cultural equipments, 41% of tourist facilities, 24% commerce, 14% of housing, 30% of the population of the city of Lyon is in the classified historical part of the city. There are many projects, in partnership with the private sector, planned to revitalize and bring to light the city’s long cultural history. Public events are organised, such as the “heritage day” and “car-less city” for people to discover their heritage on foot. For tourist policy, the condition of disabled people and foreigners are carefully taken into account. Maps, signs, transport are planned and situated through out the city. For international cooperation, the city of Lyon is helping Porto Nuovo in Benin for the preparation of its nomination of the old slave routes. In the last World Summit on Sustainable Development held in Johannesburg, Lyon has made a proposal with UNESCO for the creation of International University of Sustainable Development. Life “continues” in a living site; an historic site has to be a living organism in the future.

Mr. M. VESPER (Minister of Culture of the Land Nord Rhein Westfalen, Germany): The Zollverein Coal and Mine Industrial Complex in Westphalia, Germany, is one of the industrial sites on the World Heritage List. It is a witness of 150 years of industrial history, of the development of Coal and Steel. In 184o the operation of the mine started and the first mine shafts were built in 1850. During the 1920s more automation was demanded, and from 1928 to 1032, the famous central shaft No. 12 was constructed. Since 1933, following the beginning of the Nazi period, the buildings in this industrial complex was abandoned. In 1989, an international building exhibition was held to raise awareness of the ecological and urban aspects of the Region of the Upper Rhein and Westphalia. Industrial wasteland has become an important manmade landscape with historic characteristics, uniquely characterized by a dense complex of “industrial cathedrals.” The correct vision of harmonious and coherent development of culture is required for maintaining the value the industrial site complex. This “laboratory of modern industry “was converted into a laboratory of culture. The local authority wished the Zollverein plant to continue functioning as a “production” site; production of culture, art and to attract the historical, intellectual interest.

Mr. J-C. BEAULIEU (member of Parliament, Vice-President, Regional Council of Poitou-Charentes, France): Calling for a constructive look at our cultural heritage, since it is not merely a tool for looking at our past nostalgically. Pilgrimage route to Compostela intersects Portoir-Charentes. A major centre has been set-up, in which a network has been established to study the Romanesque heritage of the region. Some key projects have been implemented, among which is the St. Sevren Interpretation Centre for Romanesque art: preserving frescos, learning centre, studies conducted and research are among the various activities carried out at the Centre. A monastery was converted into an education centre, in which various rooms are used to conduct specific studies. The pilgrimage route to Compostela is another such project. A book on the route and guide has been published. By providing support and interpretation, digitalizing information, conducting studies, training and mobilizing the local population, heritage preservation is taking on a new dimension, functioning at the grass roots level.

Mr. Y. DAUGE (Senator of Indre et Loire, Mayor of Chinon): Two concrete examples of decentralization: the Val de Loire, with 160 Communes, 4 Departments and over 1 million inhabitants, is an extensive site, which is difficult to manage. How does France intend to manage the area? The Mission Val de Loire was created to oversee these issues. The syndicate is based in Tours, coordinating and implementing projects to valorise and develop the territory. Risk management is needed, since Loire river is in danger of flooding. Heritage management is also needed. A university was created to focus on the great rivers, to disseminate information, and train specialists and professionals. The second is Luang Prabang in Laos People’s Democratic Republic. Legitimate concerns over site management, in a country that has a centralized government, which is difficult to mobilize. Government told UNESCO that they need help, and UNESCO turned to France to engage a city to city project. Chinon was chosen, and a Convention of Cooperation was developed. Management is divided into three arms: operational (Heritage House), political and consultative. The Heritage House is funded with more than 100,000 Euros. Imagination is needed to work with multiple governments, and working on an international level requires engaging local communities.

Mr. F. BRUN (Deputy Director-General, National Geographic Institute, France): New Technologies is a new tool for the protection of World Heritage sites. He stressed that the commitment of local and regional authorities is necessarily for heritage conservation. The technology and map usage has evolved through years; mapping has been developed from ground measure to bi-dimensional and satellite mapping. By using two photos, depth, distance and height can be measured, which can be used as a tool for conservation. The new technology increased the ability to process digital images. It can also map space and human activity. For example, noise simulation can be shown, in order to measure the noise level of building situated along a highway. Another example is a map showing the risk of flooding, potential flood through a graphic image. GIS is useful to see a visual impact; ground of different level, different texture of land use and human uses etc. Brun concluded by showing a painting by Cezanne to demonstrate that the artists’ view can be that of politicians; artists see space and human activities in a painting and politicians think how these activities can be developed.

Mr. J-P. ELONG MBASSI Coordinator, Programme for Municipal Development in West and Central Africa, President of africity): Decentralisation and heritage protection in Africa. Mbassi thanked for the opportunity to have a speech in this occasion. Africa is diverse. Not all African regions share the same concerns for conservation matters. Many countries have no museums or inventory, and many officials in charge of cultural heritage have no experience in this field. Even with policies to protect heritage in existence, heritage can be pulled down in order to build a new architecture. It is necessary to separate Africa from the rest of the world. African works of art have universal heritage value; however, many are stolen from regions and stored in museums in Europe or became part of private collections. African culture is in danger, and local authorities need to take action. There are three important points to be addressed for African conservation: 1) public awareness raising by providing more information; 2) develop an inventory of cultural heritage; 3) establishing a link between conservation and development. Mbassi concluded by reminding the guests that in 2003, there will be a summit in Yaoundé, Cameroon, at which he hopes UNESCO will participate.

Mr. K. CHOONAVAN (Senator, President, Foreign Affairs Commission, Kingdom of Thailand): Discussed the process of decentralization and protection of heritage in Asia (Thailand). Four World Heritage sites were presented:

    1. Ban Chiang- archaeological remains are seen in museums;
    2. Sukthai- neglected by the Thai government;
    3. Ayuthaya- digital image of reconstruction was shown, referred to as ‘instant restauration;’
    4. Tungyai-Huak kha Kheang wildlife Sanctuaries- there are some pressures against the site; there are 6 lead mines in the sanctuary. Over 23,000 people still live there and many affected by pollution from the mines. In 1990, there was a plan to build a new dam next to the sanctuary. The construction of a dam was cancelled thanks to intervention by NGOs, students and local communities. A lake in the sanctuary is a major source of water in the country. In 1990, the city of Bangkok decided to develop its own cultural policy, and UNESCO responded by sending an international expert to the city. With 10 millions habitants, Bangkok is a living museum.

Mr. J.M. PEREDA (Minister of Education and Culture, State of Vera Cruz, Mexico): Having reminded the necessity to find a balance between living peoples and their surroundings, Mr.Pereda has presented the different phases of heritage protection in his country, Mexico. The protection of heritage in Mexico has been considered , since the 19th century, when there was excavation of the pre-Hispanic monuments under the Plaza Mayor in Mexico City. In 1874, the first law on Monuments was established and in 1889 the first measures of safeguarding them. In 1914, Institution of Protection of Cultural Heritage was created, with field offices at various sites through out the country. This was the beginning if the first link between the local people and the government, which made the local communities mobilized in the protection of heritage. In 1966, a constitutional reform has expanded the scope of legislation for heritage protection throughout the Mexico. When INAH (National Institute of Anthropology and History) and CONACULTA (National Council of Culture and Art) centralised projects of heritage protection, over 1000 historical sites were listed. Participation of federal states and local people is crucial to assure a sustainable safeguarding. Since the monuments imply the history of indigenous culture, heritage buildings must maintain a strong link with the intangible culture.

VIDEO-CONFERENCE LINK WITH DAKAR (this portion will be added soon)

Mr. M. El FEKI (President, Foreign Affairs Commission, Egyptian National Assembly): Literature, law and education are deeply rooted in French culture. Recent events have shown brutality towards heritage, and misunderstandings between modernisation and Westernisation render the situation difficult to solve. Some projects are underway, among them the plan to construct a new Egyptian museum that will replace the older 19th Century buildings. The idea, co-supported by the Italian Government, will be to consolidate the collections, both Pharaonic and Islamic into one institution.

ROUNDTABLE:

Mrs. M. YANG (Deputy-Director, UNESCO World Heritage Centre): Mrs. Yang began the roundtable discussions by putting forth two questions on how central governments are limited, and in what kinds of institutions is restructuring necessary?

Mr. F. BANDARIN (Director, UNESCO World Heritage Centre): The Director of the World Heritage Centre called for the participants in the roundtable to draw conclusions to this dense but enriching day. UNESCO’s mission can only be successful if they are in partnership with other players, such as parliamentary organisations. Legislation is fundamental. Parliaments are the bodies to decide budget, and policies. Fundraising for heritage conservation. Strategic challenge in backdrop of decentralisation. Mr. Bandarin concluded these remarks to be the framework for discussion.

Mr. R. HARTLEY (Secretary of the Chamber of Local Authorities, Congress of Local and Regional Authorities of Europe, Council of Europe): The Council of Europe and the Council of Local and Regional Leaders believe that night follows day. The process of decentralisation has increased in the local impetus, and matters related to historic cities require strengthening local authorities. There is a great desire to have more cooperation with UNESCO.

Mr. J. LEGENDRE (Senator of Nord, President of the Heritage Commission at the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe): Speaking on various capacities and fiscal measures in favour of heritage. Study on various cases in the United Kingdom. Hoping to influence other countries in the European Union. Action taken to promote programmes in Africa. Study on looting in the African world. Museums, such as in Paris, inspire illicit traffic. We need to protect least developed countries. Collectively, if we take measures, we can protect other countries. Our duty is to undertake this action.

Mr. B. MITATOVIC (Member of Yugoslavian Parliament, Yugoslavia): Concerning heritage, decentralization permits us to enforce organized management. In effect, decentralization offers local authorities to have direct competence on issues of heritage management. Mr. Mitatovic recounted that at the end of the 1980’s, heritage in Yugoslavia, namely churches and mosques, which suffered devastating effects of on-going conflicts, turned to UNESCO for support and to develop a method for heritage protection, within the framework of the 1972 World Heritage Convention.

Mr. N. NOUTH (Member of Parliament, former Minister for Culture, Cambodia): Losing markers and points of reference. Aggressive attack from media. We need to consider what we can do in our national environment. Young generation is ignorant, and has lost concept of national culture. Analyse culture before providing treatment. Dynamic movement is needed. At the outset, we have to reaffirm our national identity. Enabling man to be part of his environment. We have to explain to people, to gain support. Has asked people to consider lineage and reaffirm their local identity. Worries about commercialisation and tourism. Poverty has rendered young children ignorant. While international assistance can help, we must be careful not to emulate them directly. We need to ensure that people and the community can preserve their identity. We can not separate religion and tradition from the community. Much can be done to solve these problems with legislation. The community needs to develop antibodies to protect themselves from disappearing.

Mr. Y. DAUGE (Senator of Indre et Loire, Mayor of Chinon): Just a few words on decentralisation and inter-parliamentary cooperation. We can move on to a new phase of the 1972 convention. Linking with the grass roots level. Representative bodies can work with UNESCO to move on. In conclusion, we will work together with UNESCO, we will take this initiative and streamline a strategy that will affect policy making.

Mr. FRELOT(French Ministry of Foreign Affairs): Development banks are not active in cultural heritage, but urbanism and housing problems are of their interest. “Finding finance” is difficult but finding common fields of interest and bringing in new partners in worthy projects are important.

Mr. HACQUIN (Department of architecture and Heritage, French Ministry of Culture and Communication): The framework of cultural decentralisation is in a transition period. It is important to move the local authorities to the forefront, and central governments should help create strong networks with other (international) local authorities. Mr. Hacquin gave an example of a successful programme, in which Romanian locals have come to France in order to exchange ideas on technological information.

ONLINE CONFERENCE

NEWS

[Oct 22] Summary of the Paris Meeting: World Heritage, the Challenge of Decentralization

[Oct 15] Senate, Paris LIVE CHAT: 15:30~16:30 GMT+1


more...

TOOLS


CHAT NOW!

Get in touch

Questions about the congress archive, the papers or the articles? Write to us and we will point you to the right place.

Contact us